Policy     Economics     Technologies

Cans: at-source or post-consumer separation?

An assessment framework for local authorities

In the Netherlands, waste cans are collected via one of two routes: with residual waste or PMD waste (plastic, metal and drinks packaging). Many municipalities query whether separate collection of cans via PMD has benefits compared with post-consumer separation at waste-to-energy (WTE) plants. There are also questions regarding costs and service aspects. At the request of NVRD, the Dutch trade association for waste management, CE Delft has created an assessment framework to enable municipal authorities to make a more informed choice between at-source and post-consumer separation of packaging cans. In this context, post-consumer separation is taken to mean recovery of metals from bottom ash after incineration at a WTE plant. The assessment framework includes considerations of environmental impact, costs and service.

In the case of steel cans, it makes no difference environmentally whether they are collected with PMD waste or recovered at WTE plants. With aluminium cans, collection with PMD may presently have a slight environmental edge on average, because a number of WTE plants have a somewhat lower recovery rate for aluminium. With respect to costs, PMD collection of cans appears to be slightly more expensive down the chain as a whole, by around € 1.50 per capita per annum. These costs depend very much on how collection is organized, though. In practice it is ultimately service considerations that will often be the deciding factor, particularly in municipalities with ‘reverse collection’ or a system involving differentiated tariffs.


Geert Bergsma
Erik Roos Lindgreen

Delft, March 2017

Cans: at-source or post-consumer separation? (only available in Dutch)

Further information can be obtained from  Geert Bergsma

Tweets by @cedelft

Column Frans Rooijers - Overdag, als niemand thuis is, schijnt de zon. "Frictie tussen zomer en winter" op Energiep… https://t.co/hxYYdo4JDG
15-11-2017 10:11

Rapport - Energiebesparing in verkeer en vervoer: factsheets ten behoeve van de Nationale Energieverkenning 2017 https://t.co/fW2zzVRkQp
25-10-2017 14:28

Rapport - #Biobased #plastics in a #circular #economy. Policy suggestions for biobased and biobased biodegradable p… https://t.co/nL8CksIC6F
25-10-2017 14:11

Vacature Junior secretaresse https://t.co/4ybXcViypS #vacature #junior #secretaresse #werk #delft
24-10-2017 06:08

Report - Regulating speed: a short-term measure to reduce maritime GHG emissions https://t.co/SDnPBD0WtP
19-10-2017 08:45